About Catalli Insurance Brokers

Catalli Insurance Brokers has been serving the San Francisco Bay Area as a family run business for over 60 years. Customer loyalty, quality service and highly personalized business have kept us a leading insurance provider for San Mateo County.

Companies Represented

  • Aegis Insurance
  • California Earthquake Authority
  • Foremost Insurance
  • Geovera Insurance
  • Hagerty Insurance
  • Hudson Insurance
  • Markel Insurance
  • Mercury Insurance
  • Nationwide Insurance
  • Palomar Insurance
  • Progressive Insurance
  • Safeco Insurance
  • Stillwater Insurance

Catalli Insurance Brokers Agents

Insurance Products Offered

  • Auto Insurance
  • Boat Insurance
  • Business Insurance
  • Commercial Auto Insurance
  • Condo Insurance
  • Dwelling Fire Insurance
  • Home Insurance
  • Landlord Insurance
  • Motorcycle Insurance
  • Renters Insurance
  • Umbrella Insurance


  • Venice L. 3 months ago

    Tony was very responsive, honest and did what he could to save us money on home and auto insurance. He guided us through the process and made sure we received the right kind of insurance for our needs. Highly recommend!

  • Chris K. 3 months ago

    I have trusted Catalli Insurance with my home and auto insurance for over 20 years. Why? They are best around- why would you deal directly with insurance companies or stick with a particular one out of habit when you can have the professionals (Tony and Paul) get you the best deal? And if your home insurer won't renew or you can't get coverage on a new home for any reason (fire zone?), Catalli will most likely be able to find you a policy. Good guys to work with.

  • M H. 4 months ago

    Tony is very responsive and helpful. I introduced my son to him for home owner insurance. He offered most competitive rate and explained patiently for any clauses that I didn't understand. Words cannot fully express my appreciations to him! Highly recommended!!!

  • Kevin M. 5 months ago

    I have been with Catalli Insurance for many years. They have always been incredibly helpful, and upfront about my insurance questions. They alert me about insurance savings all along the way. They are a highly reputable organization that I have trusted, and will continue to trust in the years to come.

  • Bob P. 6 months ago

    I used Catalli Insurance Brokers to purchase new life insurance. Getting insurance for me isn't easy, and Tony stepped up and helped me find a great policy for a reasonable price. It was a very easy process for me and Tony handled all of the legwork. Tony is extremely responsive and gets things done right away. A few months after I got the insurance, there was a technical challenge at the insurance provider, and Tony was great in helping me to resolve the issue with his contacts and get my insurance provider back on track. I highly recommend Tony and Catalli Insurance brokers for all of your insurance needs!

  • Michele 6 months ago

    The folks at Catalli are incredibly nice, responsive and helpful! It's really nice to be able to speak with actual "people" when trying to resolve insurance matters, especially Tony -- he's great. Would highly recommend them to anyone who is looking for new insurance!

  • Scott G. 7 months ago

    The communication levels with your team are top notch. I have always gotten quick and accurate responses for policy information or general questions. Both Karen and Debbie have always been courteous, kind and empathetic.

  • Jonathan W. 7 months ago

    Joe is very responsive and personable and I trust him

  • Julie D. 7 months ago

    My family and I have been clients of Catalli Insurance for over 40 years! They are courteous, helpful and prompt. Throughout the years, they have personally worked with me to get the insurance policies honed in to cover all of our needs. I have always felt that the personable service that they provide has given me peace of mind.

  • Andreas N. 7 months ago

    I have been with Catalli for almost 10 years... They are a great family owned brokerage that has helped get through the years. Always able to connect with their staff for any issues. They take the time to answer all my questions and make sure I understand the ins and out of my coverage. I have used them for Home and auto insurance and have recommended them to every one I know.

  • Jason B. 7 months ago

    I've used Catalli Insurance Brokers my entire life since it was the company that my family used. In fact, my entire family has been clients for just as long. Great personalized service, competitive rates and let you know when there are ways to save money by bundling services. Highly recommend this small family run business.

  • Alejandro R. 7 months ago

    I've had Catalli insurance for a little over 30 years and, throughout this time, we've had a couple of accidents -unfortunately- but you guys have been there for me and my family, no matter what! I've enjoyed great coverage for decades for my whole family at a great price, compared to other insurers. I used to have AAA back in the day because I wanted the best, however, when I realized I was overpaying, I decided it was time to shop around, and that’s when I came across Catalli Insurance, and the rest is history! I have saved thousands, tens of thousands, while getting great coverage, great service, and peace of mind. I’ll never forget the day I walked into your San Mateo office way back then… it’s been one of the best decisions I have ever made. It’s a pleasure to be one of your clients, you guys are the BEST! Thanks for your service for all these years! Alex

  • Lisa R. 8 months ago

    Catalli Insurance Brokers: Same great agents for years so continuity of great is great! Questions answered vs. vague generic answers. Feel part of their team in picking the right policy and knowing why it is right for you vs. a sales pitch with no justifications on decisions. And, if comparing other insurance companies including AAA where you get a free gift just to compare...Catalli still ended up cheaper!

  • Deborah C. 8 months ago

    Quick responses. Staff members always pleasant and helpful.

  • Susan P. 8 months ago

    Whenever I have needed them Catalina Insurance has always acted quickly to help me resolve my problem. I am grateful for their support.

  • Rudy C. 8 months ago

    Always knowledgeable about my insurance needs. Always on top of my insurance needs.

  • Oliver Y. 8 months ago

    Very knowledgeable and customer friendly.

  • Michael D. 8 months ago

    Tony has always been a huge help in getting me the lowest price possible, especially after after my fender-bender. Looking forward to working with Tony for a long time to come.

  • Aline D. 8 months ago

    I’ve been with Catalli for over 30 years and simply don’t need to look any where else for my insurance needs. Houses, cars, and helping my kids to become insured as left the nest. Always helpful and will take time to answer all my questions and get me the best price and coverage.

  • Beckilynn M. 8 months ago

    Tony Catalli is extremely thorough, responsive, and always finds us the best deal across multiple vendors. We appreciate how available the staff is at Catalli Insurance. It's rare to find a business these days where you don't have to wade through multiple robots in order to speak to an actual human. Thanks Catalli Insurance!

  Displaying reviews 1 - 20 of 122 in total  

Leave a Review


Agency's Business Hours

  • Monday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Tuesday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Wednesday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Thursday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Friday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Saturday Closed
  • Sunday Closed
  • Mon 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Tue 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Wed 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Thu 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Fri 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Sat Closed
  • Sun Closed

Languages Spoken

  • English

States Licensed In

Britebee Logo
Oklahoma City, Oklahoma | Send Us an Email
Privacy Policy | © 2021 BriteBee. All Rights Reserved.