About Shield Insurance Agency

Tj Simmons is a 3rd Generation Insurance Agent - His GrandFather Started in the Industry in 1967 - Tj's Career Goal is to Create Life Lasting relationships with Families and Businesses in the Community - he hopes to bring value to their relationship - and make sure that his Clients are Protected and Taken care of. Shield Insurance has a Life and Health Department - A personal Lines department - and a Commercial lines Department - we are your one stop shop! When you work with us - you know us by name - we know you by name - and we care about you.

Companies Represented

  • Aaa Auto Insurance
  • American Strategic Insurance Asi
  • Foremost Insurance
  • Grange Mutual Casualty Company
  • Liberty Mutual
  • Liberty Mutual Commerial Insurance
  • Liberty Mutual Insurance
  • Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company
  • Philadelphia Insurance
  • Progressive
  • Safeco
  • State Auto Insurance Companies

Shield Insurance Agency Agents

Insurance Products Offered

  • Auto
  • Boat
  • Business
  • Classic Car
  • Commercial
  • Commercial Auto
  • Commercial Property
  • Contractor
  • General Liability
  • Health
  • Home
  • Landlord
  • Life
  • Mobile Home
  • Motorcycle
  • Recreation
  • Renters
  • Specialty
  • Workers Comp


  • Allie S. 3 months ago

    Joe responded very quickly to any and all questions my fiancé and I had. He was willing to explain every aspect of the quote that he gave us and was very knowledgeable about the topics at hand.

  • Rafael B. 3 months ago

    Joe Peiffer has professionalism with Customers. This Shield Insurance Agency has better price for my 6 Months Liability Auto Insurance than other Auto Insurance Companies. Good Coverage too. I recommend it.

  • Kristina G. 3 months ago

    After my last insurance agent left me out to dry while experiencing difficulties during this pandemic, I was scrambling to figure out what to do. I reached out to Dan Dupree and within less than an hour total we squared away my new policy. He made it a simple and painless process. Strongly recommend!

  • Ma Kenzie S. 3 months ago

    Dan Dupree has been my insurance agent for about a year now and he is the most helpful and professional agent I’ve ever worked with. He is knowledgeable and very responsive. I have gotten, home, auto, and now ATV insurance through him! He always gets me the best deal and walks me through everything step by step. Thank you to Shield for having great employees!

  • Derek J. 4 months ago

    Saved a ton of money compared to my previous insurance policy. Daniel Dupree has been fantastic to work with every time I need something.

  • Judd B. 4 months ago

    I’ve used shield for all my insurance needs for last few years , and have been very satisfied. They are always amazing at communication Current account manager Liz , has done a phenomenal job , very much appreciated. Past account manager Melissa also did a phenomenal job, was always impressed and satisfied. 10/10 local business

  • Mikaela P. 4 months ago

    Very organized and efficient office along with a very friendly and knowledgeable staff!

  • Sarah H. 4 months ago

    I called for a quote early in July and by the 3rd my insurance was in place and I am very happy w the speed and ease of the whole process. 2 thumbs up

  • Melody K. 6 months ago

    Melissa was great! Knowledgeable, quick and detail orientated I was able to work through a quote to purchasing a policy quickly. She gave me great advice that kept my best interest in mind. Highly recommended!

  • Jr H. 7 months ago

    Worked with Joe Peifer and he was great. He worked diligently to get us the proper amount of coverage at the best cost. A pleasure to work with.

  • Houston M. 8 months ago

    Shield Insurance has been great to work with! TJ is very prompt whenever I have questions or need to add new policies. Give them a call! :)

  • Melissa U. 8 months ago

    Matt saved me money and made the experience so easy! Even sent my family to him. Highly recommend!!

  • Joe R. 9 months ago

    Great company who not only gave superior services but also helped assist in providing me equal, if not better coverage in insurance when I needed it the most. Very transparent with how they figure costs, great at communication and they have provided many of my clients similar results with effective, fast and affordable services. I highly recommend this company and their team.

  • Joy 11 months ago

    Worst Ins agency ever!!!! Don't help you when you have a claim. They didn't even call us to see how we are and how things are going!! We called them cause we never heard from the adjuster handling the claim and out agent never called us back! No help. We had a lot of coverage on many auto & homes. Other people also told us this agency should have cared and helped you! Don't waste your money with this agency!!!

  • Beth B. about 1 year ago

    Valina at Shield Insurance Agency is great to work with and found good coverage for me at a much lower price than I'd previously been paying (home and auto insurance). She was very quick to respond to questions and helpful in explaining the policies and providing information on the insurance company I ended up going with. Last year when I first moved back to Michigan I went through multiple hoops and it took many phone calls over literally 3 months with my previous carrier to get the policy information correct. It was super easy and no such problems with Shield Insurance Agency. Thank you. Definitely a 5 star experience I'm happy to recommend!

  • Amanda T. over 1 year ago

    Attentive and HELPFUL company, I would highly recommend!

  • Nick F. over 1 year ago

    I wish I could give them a sixth star! Finally an insurance agency focused on the customer! I'm so grateful to TJ and the Simmons family for not just completely handling my commercial insurance nightmare, but giving me a much better price for it while making sure I have the coverage I need. Thanks so much again!

  • Kimberly C. about 2 years ago

    Been with them a year and none of the steady increase that happens as soon as I signed on with another agency.

  • Renae M. over 2 years ago

    We switched all of our personal and commercial policies over to Shield and we are more than satisfied! When you have questions they are quick to respond and very friendly as well! Everything is easily understandable and NO hidden fees which is excellent! I highly recommend them for any of your insurance needs whether it be personal or commercial!

  • Daniel D. about 7 years ago

    We have had a wonderful experience with Shield Insurance Agency. We needed to make a change in insurance as my wife went from being a full time teacher to part-time. The wonderful insurance we got through her school system would have been just too expensive. Andy was super helpful in guiding us through our options, and we couldn't be happier. We highly recommend Shield Insurance Agency!

  Displaying all 20 reviews  
britebee response time bot

Leave a Review


Agency's Business Hours

  • Monday 8:30 AM – 5:30 PM
  • Tuesday 8:30 AM – 5:30 PM
  • Wednesday 8:30 AM – 5:30 PM
  • Thursday 8:30 AM – 5:30 PM
  • Friday 8:30 AM – 5:30 PM
  • Saturday 9:00 AM – 1:00 PM
  • Sunday Closed
  • Mon 8:30 AM – 5:30 PM
  • Tue 8:30 AM – 5:30 PM
  • Wed 8:30 AM – 5:30 PM
  • Thu 8:30 AM – 5:30 PM
  • Fri 8:30 AM – 5:30 PM
  • Sat 9:00 AM – 1:00 PM
  • Sun Closed

Britebee Logo
(877) 962-7483 | Oklahoma City, Oklahoma | Send Us an Email
Privacy Policy | © 2020 BriteBee. All Rights Reserved.