About Integrity Personal Insurance

We believe in doing the right thing even when no one is watching. We take pride in understanding the unique needs of every client and providing a tailored insurance plan that will protect them when they need it most. At our core, Integrity is built on culture. Reid Fisher and Johnny Marvin founded Integrity to be a fun place to work where people are valued everyday.

Companies Represented

  • Bristol West
  • Encompass
  • Foremost
  • Hippo
  • Kemper
  • Mercury
  • Mission Select
  • National General
  • Progressive
  • Safeco
  • State Auto
  • Travelers

Integrity Personal Insurance Agents

Insurance Products Offered

  • Atv Insurance
  • Auto Insurance
  • Commercial Insurance
  • Condo Insurance
  • Homeowners Insurance
  • Renters Insurance
  • Rv Insurance


  • Cyndi B. 19 days ago

    Melissa Fruscella was my Intergrity agent and she was amazing. Not only did she find me better coverage but the savings were great! It was so painless working with her and feeling the confidence she had in helping me. I highly recommend Melissa and Integrity for your insurance needs.

  • Randa D. 24 days ago

    This is a great company that cares for their customers! I could tell how much Chanel cared about finding me the best deal and worked promptly on finding me a deal that saved me a lot of money! I always recommend Chanel at Integrity Insurance to all of my friends looking to save money on their insurance!

  • Debbie D. about 1 month ago

    I have been putting off getting new insurance for my house and car. I asked a friend who she used and bingo - got the best agent ever. I am amazed at her service. Prompt, professional, courteous etc etc. I now have better coverage for a lot less than I was paying. You actually get to speak to a real person EVERY time, that alone is worth its weight in gold! Thank you Courtney Hathcock

  • Zac W. about 1 month ago

    Y’all need to stay strapped so you don’t get clapped. these rates are killer! Also, Maddie is the best insurance agent this world has ever known. 10/10 highly recommend

  • Nicola M. about 2 months ago

    Courtney Hathcock with Integrity Personal Insurance has been wonderful to work with. Not only is she knowledgeable but she's also extremely patient and took the time to answer our many, many questions. She found a home policy for us that we feel incredibly happy and confident with. I couldn't recommend Courtney enough! Thank you 😀

  • Dante O. about 2 months ago

    I found Integrity via Dave Ramsey's site. We have been using a major carrier for over 10 yrs for home and auto. Our son was about to get his drivers license and our carrier wanted to increase our rate over $4k annually! This is what drove us to find an independent agency. Melissa Fruscella reached out to me after I submitted our contact info and she is a ROCK STAR! Great response time, listened to our concerns, compared our current coverage to the market and not only dropped the rates significantly but also got us better coverage! Best of the all the entire process from shopping rates to changing carriers was all handled by Melissa with a few clicks from me to complete the process. She even handled the cancellation of our existing policies. Do yourself and your family a favor, put Melissa and Integrity to work for you! I wish we did it 10 yrs ago.

  • Gage W. about 2 months ago

    I felt like a valued customer and client! Mathew Palmer aptly described the system and answered all of my questions quickly and fully. I would have to say this is by far one of the best experiences I have ever had with an insurance company.

  • Kayla H. about 2 months ago

    I really enjoyed getting to work with Matthew Palmer! He had well informed answers for all of my questions and made finding the right insurance an overall great experience. I now feel educated and confident in my choice! Needless to say, I am extremely thankful for the kindness and dedication that I received. I would highly recommend Integrity and Matthew to anyone!!

  • Hunter H. about 2 months ago

    I LOVED getting to work with Matthew Palmer. Besides knowing insurance very well, he is a spectacular guy! Very helpful- definitely referring friends to him. Thanks Matthew for helping me save money!

  • Paul B. about 2 months ago

    I recently had the opportunity to shop for a new insurance carrier and Rory Barcheski was recommended by a family friend. He quickly responded to my request and found both auto and homeowners insurance for me at the same coverage levels with a very reasonable savings. It took less than 3 days to sign all the documents and get coverage. Great Service and very professional and he kept me informed along the entire process. I've already recommended him to other family members.

  • Tonya D. about 2 months ago

    I happened across a recommendation for Courtney Hathcock with Integrity Insurance. I wasn't looking to switch carriers, but having worked with an insurance broker in the last state I lived in, I was interested to see what Integrity offered. I contacted Courtney via email c.hathcock@insureintegrity.com and had a response within minutes. I sent her my details and she dug in right away. The following morning she had two great options for me that actually increased coverage that made sense for my family but kept my rate the same for mortgage and reduced my auto $100 a month. She went line by line and explained what each item covered and why it was beneficial for me to have. When I had questions she went BEYOND, to give explanation as well as asked other professionals when she wasn't as familiar with the topic as she preferred to be. I had so much fun talking to Courtney and feel she had my best interest at heart. I am excited to begin what I think will be a long, enjoyable relationship with Courtney and Integrity Personal Insurance. Thank you Courtney!!

  • Kyle C. 2 months ago

    Courtney Hathcock was absolutely phenomenal. She helped me with all my polices across the board. She was persistent in finding the best value and the right policy for my wants and needs. Shes been available anytime I have needed her thus far. Shes also super friendly, fun, and informative. I highly recommend giving her a call. She will treat you right.

  • Mitchell M. 2 months ago

    I really enjoyed working with Rory! Very transparent and very quick to respond to all of my questions. He will take care of you and find the best deal for your needs!

  • Lln 8. 3 months ago

    Melissa Fruscella was extremely helpful and patient waiting for my responses. She answered all of my questions quickly and helped us find lower home owners insurance! Thank you Integrity!

  • Bob L. 3 months ago

    Courtney has been fantastic! Very professional and always honest in her recommendations for insurance. Highly recommend using Courtney for ALL your insurance needs.

  • Sherri W. 3 months ago

    Courtney was able to put together a very comprehensive, competitive quote for us upon our recent move to Texas! We have purchased Home, Auto and Umbrella coverage and are paying less than we had in another state with less exposures. Thank you for the great job Courtney!

  • Michael F. 3 months ago

    I worked with Lee Siegel and he was very helpful and intuitive in walking me through line by line each detail of my policy! He made everything easy to understand and made sure that we were getting the best rate without sacrificing coverage. I definitely recommend using Lee for future insurance needs!

  • Daniel B. 3 months ago

    Dylan Buhrow did another fantastic job getting us the insurance we needed. Dylan originally got us car insurance but we were stuck with our homeowners. Wife and I decided to refinance our home and that opened the door to shop for new insurance. Dylan Buhrow and Integrity were right there ready to help find an awesome deal. Never hurts to have an agent that is going to shop and fight to get you the best deal possible. Excited to have all of our insurance under the Integrity roof now!

  • Debbie H. 3 months ago

    Working with Rory Barcheski regarding my insurance needs was an excellent experience. He was responsive, knowledgeable and helped find coverage that significantly reduced my insurance premiums while also providing me with better coverage. He's a great listener and thoughtfully answers all questions. I highly recommend him.

  • Catherine B. 3 months ago

    Great experience working with Rory. Within 24 hours of initial contact, Rory and I had spoken about what I was looking for and he found my exact same policy for over $100 less than my previous agent. Efficient and honest. Looking forward to continuing to work with him.

  Displaying reviews 1 - 20 of 29 in total  

Leave a Review


Agency's Business Hours

  • Monday 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Tuesday 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Wednesday 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Thursday 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Friday 8:30 AM – 4:00 PM
  • Saturday Closed
  • Sunday Closed
  • Mon 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Tue 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Wed 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Thu 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Fri 8:30 AM – 4:00 PM
  • Sat Closed
  • Sun Closed

Britebee Logo
(877) 962-7483 | Oklahoma City, Oklahoma | Send Us an Email
Privacy Policy | © 2020 BriteBee. All Rights Reserved.