About Dave Pettengill: Dave Pettengill is an independent insurance agent known for advising individuals and companies about their insurance needs. Dave has been in the insurance industry for over 17 years. He is credited as being one of the youngest Exclusive Agents with Allstate back in 2007. Dave has now transitioned to being independent to provide the most possible options for his clientele. Dave is a two-time voted president of the local networking chapter in his community. He is a lifelong Michigan resident and loves traveling within the great lakes state, enjoying craft beer and rooting for the local sports teams. He loves traveling with his wife Krystal and his favorite job of all is being a father of three boys.

Companies represented: Citizens, Hanover, Safeco, Liberty Mutual, State Auto, Progressive, Foremost, Michigan Millers, The Hartford, Grange, AAA, Universal, American Modern, Markel, Allstate, Accident Fund, Berkshire Hathaway, Nationwide, Allied

Languages spoken: English

Licensed in: IL, MI, OH, TX

Specialty Areas

  • small-business-and-home-owners

Insurance Products Offered

  • Recreational
  • Life
  • Business
  • Home
  • Auto


  • Crystal A 8 months ago

    Exceptional customer service. Very easy to work with and always quick to respond to any questions. I highly recommend this office.

  • Matt Keway about 1 year ago

    I would highly recommend Rubie and Michigan Insurance, she is very compassionate at what she does and you can rest assured that your home or auto policy will keep you covered when needed.

  • gothic chick about 2 years ago

    If I leave a message my call is returned within a satisfactory time frame and if I have a question you are quick to get me an answer

  • Scott Carter about 2 years ago

    Dave took the time to match me to the right company and coverage to fulfill my needs for as cheap as possible. In addition, he made me feel very comfortable working with him.

  • Anna Marie Bartels about 3 years ago

    One of the best insurance -acquiring experience in my 37 years in business. Rubie Williams and her partner Dave Pettengill were patient in our process and attending to all our questions and concerns. They were mindful of budget and had excellent suggestions. I look forward to sending more business their way.

Have you purchased insurance from this agency before?

Let us know what you thought:

Agent's Business Hours

  • Monday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Tuesday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Wednesday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Thursday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Friday 9:00 AM – 4:00 PM
  • Saturday Closed
  • Sunday Closed